Ranking #1 and Getting Zero Traffic: How AI Is Rewriting Digital Search
Featuring: Brian Betkowski and Ed Haines with Andy Hendricks of Grey Matter
Digital search spent 25 years becoming a science. Now, about half of all searches run through AI tools or AI summaries, and much of what marketers knew no longer applies.
Overview
In this episode of Strategy That Works, Brian Betkowski and Ed Haines sit down with Andy Hendricks of Grey Matter to discuss why credibility across the whole web now matters more than your own site, why original research and data give AI something worth citing, and how ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini each favor different sources. Andy also explains why results take six to nine months to build and shares a simple way to check where you stand: list ten questions your buyers ask, run them through the major AI tools, and see who gets recommended.
PODCAST TRANSCRIPT
Andy Hendricks
I would say what really still works is anything you have that’s original. AI can regurgitate anything. So if you have something that only you have, that’s going to be valuable to AI. So original research, original data, you’re taking something from your customers that only you can get essentially, that’s a way to give AI some authority, some credibility and give them something they can cite.
Brian Betkowski
Welcome back to Jabian’s Strategy That Works podcast. My name is Brian Betkowski. I’m here with my friend and colleague, Ed Haines, back in the Atlanta headquarters studio. Excited for another great podcast.
Ed Haines
Excellent. And a new location.
Brian Betkowski
Yeah. And so I wanted to start off. We have a really interesting topic today and a really interesting industry, and I wanted to start with just a visualization. Imagine you’re working in an industry, the industry is only 30 years old, which is not uncommon for lots of technology industries, but let’s call it late 90s. The industry literally was born in the late 90s. You’ve been working in that industry all your career. The most seasoned veteran in that industry can only be 30 years in that industry. So the average tenure in the industry is probably seven to 10 years, something like that. You’ve been there your whole career. You’ve been honing the art of this. You know the ins and outs, you know the inputs, you know the outputs empirically, quantitatively. You know how to put a dollar in, a quarter in and get a dollar out. And then AI comes along like in a lot of other industries and literally turns this industry a hundred percent on its head.
Brian Betkowski
The art that became a science is now once again an art. And you basically have to relearn this industry all over again. And that industry is digital search. There’s lots of industries that you probably could put that in, but today we’re going to talk about the digital search industry, otherwise also known sometimes as SEO and other acronyms, but digital search. And before we jump into it, though, I want you to put a little more color on that disruption and how crazy of an industry change this has been.
Ed Haines
Right. And when we think about this, it’s about obviously how people use AI and how they have searched before. But more importantly, what we’re going to talk about today is how do businesses react to that and how do they adapt to that? And so when we think about how searches are done, we put them in two different categories. There’s one, I’m in my chat with Claude or OpenAI and I’m asking a question. It goes out to the web and it gives me some recommendations. And then there’s also the search, the traditional search. So it might be Google where I’m doing a search and up pops this AI kind of view. And so suddenly what we find out, I suppose companies are finding out how to work through is how do I not just end up in the search, but how do I actually end up in a buying decision early rather than just have a search and then continue on?
Ed Haines
And I do have some stats around this. So in 2022, to your point about being a new industry, there were zero AI searches because it just didn’t exist. So that’s a good base number. And then in 2024, so four years later, 33% of the searches done were done through AI, either one of those two channels we just talked about. And now in 2026 it’s 50%. So you can see a trajectory that obviously is going to make a difference. And next year who knows what it’ll look like and likely very soon it’ll be 100%. And so thinking about how those searches are really impacting things, there’s another stat here which says, okay, if you do the Google type search, when you put it in and it pops up, it pops up with here’s AI telling you what the view is and underneath you’ve got the traditional clicks there.
Ed Haines
So even in that scenario, 50% of those links get clicked. And so it’s rapidly becoming extinct essentially. And it’s not just the way it’s being given to you and the way it’s being presented, it’s also the way it’s being collected. And I think that’s obviously what we’re going to talk through.
Brian Betkowski
Yeah. And a lot of companies, to your point, have literally built their whole sales and marketing plans over the science that they understood about how search worked and how people interacted with search and how customers interacted with search, and now that gets totally turned on its head. And so some people would be totally freaked out by this. You’re in an industry that gets turned up on its head. The good news is we have a guest today who’s not totally freaked out about that. Andy Hendricks from Grey Matter is joining us today. And fortunately, Andy was involved prior to the AI revolution and knows what search was and now is helping lead the way on what search will be and what search is. So thank you for joining us today.
Andy Hendricks
Glad to be here.
Brian Betkowski
All right. So we’re going to start off with just a big question. We’ll go right to something practical for our listeners. If you think about the world pre-AI and the world now, if you had to tell someone, a marketer, someone in advertising or someone leading an organization the top two or three things that they just have to be thinking about in this new world, let’s just start big there and then we’ll go from there.
Andy Hendricks
Yeah, I’d say the biggest thing you need to think about is PR and establishing your business’s credibility. You need to be trusted by more than just yourself. So you need to talk the talk and walk the walk, where previously you could maybe get away with just talking the talk about yourself.
Brian Betkowski
Why is it you can’t get away with it anymore?
Andy Hendricks
I think in the previous search world, there’s a lot that had to do with your own website, your own brand, and so it was really easy to build that up yourself in a vacuum. Now AI wants to see what the whole universe says. So it’s looking beyond just your website, just your brand. It wants to see what are customers saying about you? What is the news saying about you? What is social media saying about you? So you really need a strong presence in the entire web rather than just in your own little quarter and hope to get recommended.
Brian Betkowski
So is it something that people can, for lack of a better term, buy their way into? I mean, can you still buy your way into or are you talking true organic, got to figure out and make it happen the old-fashioned way?
Andy Hendricks
I think yes and no. Of course there’s pay-to-play media, you can pay for editorials, so you can buy your way into it a little bit. But I also think that credibility really comes from something that’s organic, something that’s natural, something where you could see this is the true opinion of real people. AI is chasing a really good customer experience. So if you can show you’re the answer that’s going to give whoever’s typing in this chat a really good experience, that’s the real key. And so that comes from something more organic.
Ed Haines
So being able to make sure you can deliver on that promise in the sense of you’ve got all these different data points that are feeding into AI that aren’t just about your own company’s point of view. Is that over a period of time as well? So imagine that what you did last week or last month isn’t important anymore if you’ve got to really focus on today as well.
Andy Hendricks
For sure. Definitely something that builds over time and it takes a lot of time to build. It’s one of those things where one really good article or one really good review probably isn’t going to make a difference. It’s stacking all those up over time and compiling to something like what’s the universal point of view about this company is what’s really going to make a difference.
Brian Betkowski
Would you say might be the second or third if you had to rank some things or maybe with some things that used to work that still work?
Andy Hendricks
I would say something that I think, Ed, you just touched on is the top of funnel, it still exists, but it’s getting smaller and it’s disappearing. You talked about looking at the search results, how the AI overview is answering a lot of that. I have clients where we track where they rank in Google and I have clients who are ranking number one or on page one and they’re getting zero traffic from that. So that used to be if you ranked on page one, that guaranteed traffic, which guaranteed opportunities, which guaranteed business. Now when the AI overview is answering those questions, you’re losing those shots at the top of the funnel and people are coming to you further down the funnel. They already have an answer that AI gave them. They don’t need to read your website to figure that out. And since they’re not on your website, you’re not seeing that, you’re not seeing them download your white papers or fill out a form to talk to you. And so you’re really only getting them when they’re very low in the funnel and they’re close to making a decision.
Brian Betkowski
Could that be positive in some ways? In other words, filtering out some of the noise? I mean, is it?
Andy Hendricks
It could be. It could be that you’re getting people who are more qualified, but you’re also getting a lot less. That’s kind of the trade-off is you’re getting a buyer who’s more informed, who’s probably more ready to make a decision, but you’re also getting a lot less prospects. So it’s a little of both there.
Brian Betkowski
Yeah. What are some other strategies that used to work that are still good to continue?
Andy Hendricks
I would say what really still works is anything you have that’s original. AI can regurgitate anything. So if you have something that only you have, that’s going to be valuable to AI. So original research, original data, you’re taking something from your customers that only you can get essentially, that’s a way to give AI some authority, some credibility and give them something they can cite. They love to cite something and say, “Hey, they said this, this is true.” So anything you can get that’s real data, real research is going to make a difference there.
Ed Haines
And this is why some of these content creators become so, I suppose, rich and popular very quickly, right? There’s a big role they play, I suppose, depending on the product.
Andy Hendricks
For sure. Getting that third-party endorsement from an influencer, from a content creator, that’s going to make a difference in saying, okay, if they’re saying this about you and they have all this authority, you kind of receive some of that authority by transfer and that goes towards you as well.
Brian Betkowski
Are there any channels that you see, for example, think about all the places to spend your money on those type of things, you can do events, you can do videos, you can write white papers. I mean, the list is really long. Does AI care?
Andy Hendricks
Yes and no. I would say that what’s really hard with this is that every AI is a little bit different. Gemini, the way it categorizes content is very different from how ChatGPT or how Claude does. And so for example, Gemini really loves YouTube, so they really do love video and that’s because they’re owned by Google. But ChatGPT for a lot of times was favoring Reddit very heavily because that’s a really good forum for authentic customer engagement. And so Reddit was a really big strategy for ChatGPT recently. And then for Claude, that could be a whole other site. So the answer is yes, they matter, but they matter differently to the different platforms.
Ed Haines
Do you see that being split down either the industry or the B2C versus B2B? Is there a difference?
Andy Hendricks
Yeah, I would definitely say so. I’d say you kind of see the B2B people drift towards Claude and ChatGPT and then the more user-centric people, they’re using the free tools. No one who’s using it on their own is using Perplexity for fun. So kind of learning where your buyers, what tool they use is definitely a big part of that as well.
Brian Betkowski
What about the science of it? I mean, I’ve only dabbled in it, but the Google tools for sure gave you such unbelievable insights. You could always basically tell them exactly how you wanted it to work out and they would tell you exactly how to do that. Where are we now?
Andy Hendricks
Right now it’s a little bit of a black box. We can get a little bit of insights. You can see traffic to your website from AI. Google will tell you what pages are being cited by AI. There’s some third-party platforms you can pay to get kind of an idea of what’s going on, but there’s no real input X to get Y right now. You really have to go off the bigger picture of, okay, what questions are my buyers asking and how is my content answering those questions? And there’s no real perfect way to measure that right now. You used to be able to do that with Google, you could see what pages are ranking for what keywords and know you were making a difference. It’s a lot harder to do that now. And so it’s more of a feeling than anything and just trusting, do you know your buyers and are you sure that you’re answering your buyers when they ask those questions?
Brian Betkowski
Yeah. So when you think about traditional search, you think search terms, specific words, and is that a thing anymore? Where’s that going?
Andy Hendricks
I think keywords are still a thing. The one thing you have to remember that’s happening with AI is that when people go to an AI, they’re usually not just typing consultant. They’re typing, “Hey, I’m trying to find a consultant for this to help me with this. Here’s my goal.” So they’re asking queries that are much longer, much more detailed, and that are very different from how another buyer may search. And so you still need those core terms, but you don’t want to get bogged down in the specifics as much since they vary so much from person to person.
Ed Haines
I want to go back to what you said earlier about the content needing to be original. So if you’ve got what we’ve often heard people say, “Well, they’re using AI to create content more and you’ve seen a lot more of it.” So are you saying that a handwritten, or not handwritten is the wrong word, but originally written with no M dashes type piece of content is going to be more powerful than an AI piece of content? I mean, it kind of suggests it’s like the opposite of what we would think, right?
Andy Hendricks
Not necessarily that if it was written by a person versus AI, but is the content, the data behind it original or not? Is the insights behind it original or not? Because AI can give you really good content, but it’s going to be generic content. So I can use AI to write a really generic blog post, but if I have really good data and insights that only I know, then I can write a blog post with AI that’s going to make a difference because it’s got those original insights in it.
Ed Haines
So are there tools like springing up that enable you to do that, where you could load your own content in, similar to what we see with obviously knowledge management?
Andy Hendricks
Yeah, I think the big thing is people are getting a lot better. They’re building skills for Claude or they’re building items to train their AIs like, okay, pull this data from here and use that to give me content. So I would say yeah, that’s definitely a big way the industry’s heading.
Brian Betkowski
Concept of figuring out what’s AI or not. I think we did a test on one of our original journals from 2012, which we definitely did not use AI to write. And it said it was a high likelihood, like 70% or more that it was written by AI, which is just wrong because that just didn’t even exist. And so I think it’s interesting where that’s all going. On that topic, where is this going? I mean, what do you see as the next couple years for…
Andy Hendricks
I think the biggest thing is people are starting to get personal agents, which it’s one thing to use an AI chat, but when I talk about an agent, that’s someone who’s more proactive. You may have seen Muses starting to get really big right now from Meta. And so instead of can you have an agent that doesn’t wait for you to prompt it, that anticipates your needs, that sees, “Hey, you got an email, hey, you got a calendar invite, I went ahead and pulled all this stuff together for you so you’re ready.” And then also using that on the personal side, agent says, “Hey, I saw you bought that pair of shoes. Here’s some prices for some similar ones that you may want as well.” And so I think we’re going to get really to the point of when it starts anticipating your needs rather than waiting for you to prompt it.
Brian Betkowski
Yeah. I know you mentioned that they’re not giving professionals the insights as you would normally get from Google, but it’s my understanding Google also saw what people clicked on and if other people clicked on it, then it was more likely that it was relevant. Is that happening inside of AI, you know of?
Andy Hendricks
In a way. I think AI is pushing a lot more zero-click search like we talked about, where they’re answering the question before they go to your website, but Google does try to learn and say, okay, Google wants to be the best AI, so it wants to give the best information. And so if that is getting clicked on or if that’s leading to really good follow-up discussion, it is going to use that as a signal like, “Hey, this content was right.”
Ed Haines
But what we’re seeing now maybe is a phase we’re in where because they’re competing to be the most prominent one, do you see it kind of settling out like most disruptions do?
Andy Hendricks
I think so. I think Google, they have enough market share from being the traditional search guy that Gemini and Google AI mode, the AI summary you get at the top from Google, they’ve been climbing ever since they launched. And so I do think we’ll see it settle between probably ChatGPT, Claude and Google as maybe the big three. But I do think it is a very volatile space right now and it’s almost like an arms race. Every week there’s a new model that comes out that’s bigger and better and faster. And so it’s, I think, a race to the top and a race to see. I don’t know if there’s firm stats on do people pick one because everything that I see is that people use more than one AI will compare them. At least that’s what I do in my personal life too. So that’ll be really interesting to see, do we see brand loyalty to AI or people pick one?
Brian Betkowski
So if we had a listener right now who’s saying to themselves, “Wow, yeah, I experience that same thing. I was spending money on search, it was working really well, then it stopped working really well, and I’m hearing these things you’re telling me about getting recognized on news places like, oh, that seems really overwhelming.” Practically speaking, if you said, “Okay, but I’m going to do it,” what is the time that it really takes that you’ve seen where people decide they’re going to do it the new way and start to see actual results from it?
Andy Hendricks
I think it can easily take six to nine months. I think it’s a lot of investing in content, seeing that content take hold, getting more and more recognition, getting more and more people talking about you. So it’s definitely not something that’s going to happen overnight or something you can, with Google, you could turn an ad and get traffic the next day. It’s going to be something where you have to invest a lot in and it can easily be very long-term.
Ed Haines
It’s interesting. It becomes a moat because typically you think of AI as getting rid of the moat in the sense of barrier to getting into something, but it’s interesting this is actually creating one for a lot of companies.
Brian Betkowski
Are you seeing a specific place where people are moving their money to? I mean, are they deciding to spend money on traditional marketing channels more than prior because this isn’t working as good?
Andy Hendricks
I think a big thing a lot of people do is investing more in traditional PR. So they’re making a push to getting mentioned in legacy media, getting mentioned in newspapers, news channels, things like that. And then also they’re building very in-depth social strategies. So they want people talking about them on LinkedIn, on Reddit. They want to have a presence on Reddit where if someone asks a question, a rep can jump in there and answer that question rather than leave it unanswered because they want to control the narrative, control that content that can hopefully recommend you.
Brian Betkowski
Yeah, that’s interesting.
Ed Haines
It just turns the strategy upside down in a sense, doesn’t it? And if strategy is being where you invest your money in a lot of ways, like you were hitting on before.
Brian Betkowski
Well, anything that we haven’t talked about that you wanted to hit on or top of mind for you and your firm?
Andy Hendricks
I think the biggest thing that you can think about is if it’s really hard to measure, it can be something that you can check yourself without paying for a super expensive third-party tool or about killing yourself looking at analytics dashboards every day. Just sit down and ask yourself, what are 10 questions that my buyers are asking? And scrutinize those, make them specific, make them for different stages in your funnel. And then once a week or once a month, test those in AI and just see what are those answers. And it’s not a perfect science, but that will kind of give you a pulse on, okay, who is getting recommended in what platforms? I’ll test AI mode, I’ll test Claude, I’ll test Gemini, all the different ones, and that’ll give you just kind of an idea of who’s getting recommended, who’s getting mentioned. And that can also give you some ideas of like, okay, if my buyers are asking this question and I don’t answer it, I need to start answering that. So that needs to be blog topics, that needs to be press releases, and that can give you a path that when this universe looks so huge and overwhelming, that’s kind of a way to boil it down and say, “Here’s where I can actually attack it and make a difference.”
Brian Betkowski
And you were saying something when we were talking earlier around the personalization aspect of AI is so neat. It starts to know me and it starts to do things. Sometimes it tells me the answer, I think, just that it knows I want to hear, which is not always good. Where back in the day, traditional Google paid search, if everything, all things the same, if I put the search and you put the search, we’re from the same location, there’s still budget left in the search, most likely we’ll see some of the same ads presented to us or some of the same information on the organic side. What are you seeing on the differences amongst answers?
Andy Hendricks
Yeah, that’s a great point there. You’re right, there used to be some continuity in search. There was the same 10 links that were on a page. Now, since everyone is asking slightly different questions that are more specific and they have different context from previous answers, you can ask the same question in two different chat accounts and get a completely different recommendation. Also, there’s little nuances in how you ask a question. If you ask about pricing or if you ask about who’s the best, that can skew the answer a lot more than just if you asked it generically. And so that’s one thing that’s also really hard to measure with AI, which is why the company selling AI dashboards are a kind of snake oil salesman right now because you really can’t measure how different everyone’s personal interaction is. And so that’s just one thing you have to understand is that everyone’s different from everyone else there.
Brian Betkowski
Yeah. Are you seeing people just, you mentioned testing it a little bit yourself, but are you seeing people doing mass testing where you’re literally doing thousands and thousands of searches to see what’s –
Andy Hendricks
Oh yeah. There’s definitely people who are doing that or they have automated tools that are like, “Hey, go query Claude 300 times a day, ask all these different prompts, give me the answers, summarize where I show up, summarize where I don’t.” You may be getting some insights for that or just get some big picture ideas of where you’re showing up, but that’s a thing right now. I don’t know if it’s a valuable thing, but it is something that people do.
Brian Betkowski
Yeah. We got any other thoughts and questions before you…
Ed Haines
I mean, the last one I had, you touched on the fact that the funnel was disappearing or you were invisible at the top of the funnel and you’ve moved down. How much further is it going to move down? It wouldn’t get to a point where the phone starts to ring, would it?
Andy Hendricks
It could be just order right now.
Ed Haines
There’s no phone anymore. There’s order right now. I was going to say that’s the channel, isn’t it?
Andy Hendricks
Yeah, that could be a thing where we could get to a point where it’s just one AI agent talking to another AI agent. They send their agent off to research all the companies, they pick one, they talk to that agent to buy and they take it from there. So I think right now we’ve gone from the top funnel to mid-funnel and it’ll be really interesting to see if we go further down or all the way to the bottom.
Ed Haines
But that’s a really interesting point though about actually the order process itself and how it kind of flows into that because that example with a pair of, I need a new pair of running shoes and I buy the same running shoes every year, just reorder the same ones. If it’s automatically ordering them because it knows you like that brand, how do you get yourself injected into that conversation when it’s too automatic?
Brian Betkowski
Yeah, break the loop.
Ed Haines
Yeah, break the loop.
Brian Betkowski
That’s good. Anything else that we haven’t hit on that you want to talk about?
Andy Hendricks
I think one more thing I’d say is that, like I said, this industry is volatile. What’s true today could be not true tomorrow. I mentioned Reddit was really a heavy source for ChatGPT earlier. Earlier this year, ChatGPT completely devalued Reddit and now it’s creeping up again. So it’s one of these things where you just have to understand this is a volatile space. What’s true today may not be true tomorrow.
Brian Betkowski
Frustrating.
Ed Haines
Yeah.
Ed Haines
That’s the new world we live in, isn’t it? What’s true today might not be true tomorrow.
Brian Betkowski
Yeah. Well, thank you. That was very good. Very practical experience and look forward to having you on again sometime.
Andy Hendricks
Yeah. Thanks for having me.
Ed Haines
Thanks, Andy.