Stop Throwing Inventory at the Problem: Supply Chain Planning When Volatility Is the Norm

Featuring: Brian Betkowski, Ed Haines, and Greg Giesecke

Supply chain disruptions have increased sixfold since 2019, costs have roughly doubled, and carrying extra inventory now costs far more than it did a few years ago, making smarter planning essential to protecting sales, improving cash flow, and staying competitive.

Overview

In this episode of Strategy That Works, Brian Betkowski and Ed Haines welcome back Greg Giesecke, Jabian’s head of supply chain and Denver office lead, to talk about what it takes to plan well when conditions keep changing. They discuss why the real value in supply chain planning comes from recovered sales and freed-up cash rather than headcount savings, why the lead times your vendors quote rarely match what you experience, and how focusing on the 20% of your business that drives most of the complexity changes the outcome. Greg also explains how mid-sized companies can reach parity with their current planning process in weeks instead of a year, then build from there.

PODCAST TRANSCRIPT

Greg Giesecke

There are a lot of scenarios that play out. One of the biggest things we see is that simple sourcing decisions. You buy this product from Indonesia, it’s the best quality and the cheapest item. Then tariffs went nuts. All of a sudden, this isn’t a swing of 5% or 10% in a commodity; this is a 40% move. So all of a sudden, a much more expensive option is the cheapest option because that moved.

Brian Betkowski

Welcome back to Jabian’s Strategy That Works podcast. I’m Brian Betkowski. I’m here with my friend and colleague, Ed Haines. We’re here in the Atlanta studio today, and we’ve got a really awesome guest, really expert in supply chain. It’s going to be really fun to get back into this. He’s joining us again for the second time. And I think this is one of the few folks that were talking about the post-pandemic craziness, the volatility and all the disruption that we saw post-pandemic as the new norm. I think a lot of people were talking about that as it was a really crazy thing, lots of really crazy stuff happening, especially in the supply chains. And people were perhaps hoping we would get back to what it used to be like, and that was a blip and that was not a blip. And we’ve seen that the ongoing disruption and volatility since the pandemic as the new norm.

And our guest has actually just said, “You know what? We’re going to live with that and we’re going to come up with some ways to deal with that and help our clients deal with that.” So I’m excited to jump into that. But before we do it, stats on disruption and volatility, what are you seeing?

Ed Haines

Right. And actually to add to what you’re saying, not only do we see that disruption, but then we’re also seeing the AI disruption as well. So actually having those two conversations together is going to be really fascinating. So yes, I do have some stats. So the first one, back to what you were just saying about volatility, and we’d obviously been talking about this before and the disruptions, but I thought this was a really good one. It’s from a company called Resilinc, a leading supply chain risk monitoring company. And they said that in 2019, they had roughly 3,700 disruptions that they measure across the supply chain. And the disruption could be like a factory fire or obviously something big like a war or whatever it might be. But that was 2019. And in 2024, there were 22,500. Now, some of that could obviously be associated with being able to measure a little bit more, but it’s still sixfold, which is kind of crazy.

So that suggests that pre-pandemic, there was a baseline and then here we are with these huge numbers that continue to happen. And then when we think about what has that done to the supply and demand elements of things and what that’s done to pricing, a classic example is cattle and brisket is one that I pulled up here where essentially it’s roughly double the price. And a lot of that has just been because of supply and demand and being able to ensure that you’re getting not just… You have all these different impacts from environment, from the supply chain itself, from decisions being made by the farmers, et cetera, that created this kind of demand. And then you look at, okay, so brisket is a little bit harder to do this, but if you hold stock and if you want to get through those disruptions, what does that cost you?

And so the prime interest rate has moved from 4.75 to 7% over that time and actually I think peaked around 8.5%. And so the cost of actually carrying inventory is tremendous as well. So there’s a real need to actually try and get your forecasting right, trying to get your inventory right. And then you can say, “Well, I’m going to be overly conservative about that.” And if it swings the other way, what we’re seeing as well there is big vendors actually charging a lot more for missing some of the commitments that the suppliers are making. So Walmart, for example, charges 3% of cost of goods sold on the impact of goods for anything that misses demand. And so that really strikes it, you got to nail it. You got to get it right down the middle from cost perspective, but also from a customer perspective.

Brian Betkowski

Obviously we all live it in our daily lives and we see it on TV all the time, whether it’s a war or the latest oil impacts or whatever it is. I think what we talked about with our guest and we’re going to talk about more today is how this is the new norm. And it’s not that it’s time to guess what the future’s going to be like. We have no idea, but it’s time to plan for that accordingly and it’s time to do something about that. And whether that’s saving money on working capital or from an inventory perspective or recovering lost sales, whatever it is, we’re going to figure it out and have a focus on those outcomes. So without further ado, we’ll introduce our guest today. Welcome, Greg Giesecke from Denver. He leads our Denver office, is a shareholder, and is also our head of supply chain and our Linchpin offering, which we’ll talk more about today. So welcome.

Greg Giesecke

Thank you.

Brian Betkowski

All right. Well, I know you study not only just the markets and supply chain, but you have obviously a big finance and strategy background as well. And so tell us about what did you see that had you come up with Linchpin? What is it and what’s your just general take on where we are in the market?

Greg Giesecke

Yeah. So Ed kind of hit on it, but there’s really two things that are happening over the past handful of years that are driving volatility wildly. And they’re both kind of good news stories when you think about investing in and solving problems in your business. So you hit on a couple of stats there. Inflation since pre-COVID until now on average for the cost of goods that a lot of companies buy, their products have gotten about twice as expensive. They’ve got a huge level of increase in that just cost of procurement. And not only have they gone up, but it’s the volatility. So they’re not consistently more expensive. They’re not more expensive in the same way. It’s making it a much tougher decision to drive. The other piece is those interest rates. So it could be four times as expensive as it is to throw money at the problem, just to say, let’s buy a bunch of inventory and hold it, that’ll solve our risk issue.

But in reality, what happens is it takes a continual optimization. And that’s what we’ve seen over the past really probably two years is that ability, whether it’s because of sheer horsepower and computational power or our ability to solve what we call linchpins within a business, your optimization isn’t, let’s do it once and let’s see what happens and operate for a year. We can be doing that optimization function daily. We can literally be looking at how much inventory should I hold, re-baseline my targets pretty continually when we go through that.

Brian Betkowski

And what was the thing that stopped people from doing that two, three years ago, 10 years ago?

Greg Giesecke

Yeah, there’s kind of two sides of it. One, if you’re kind of throwing money at the problem and interest rates are cheap, maybe that’s the right optimization function. The right thing to do oftentimes is solve it by holding a little bit more product. If the cost of a missed sale or the cost of holding that product balance out, that’s essentially your optimization function. And not only were costs lower, but they were pretty stable. And now we’re seeing brisket goes up and then drops down. Just the cost of getting a shipping container has changed tenfold since the pandemic, whether that’s because of the Suez Canal getting blocked, energy prices, there’s all sorts of things that drive that, but the volatility is all over the place. So the concept of making a decision and then just operating on a fixed function, that’s not what’s needed to run your business and we’re not operating under the same constraints.

So we have the horsepower to be able to set up models that run your business. And one of the things we talk about all the time is for most of what a company’s business is, it’s pretty straightforward. There’s a process, not a lot of exceptions we run, but it’s really the Pareto rule where 10, 20, 30% of your business drives almost all of the complexity. So for our ability to focus on those weird outliers, we have the opportunity to focus on those with this Linchpin solution.

Ed Haines

And if you’re a smaller business, does that become more important because you don’t have as much volume, so those outliers have more of an impact?

Greg Giesecke

Percentage-wise, the outliers are huge, but when you talk about Walmart, there are fields of PhDs who think about running optimization functions all the time. And Walmart, one of the five largest businesses in the world, can afford to hire pricing PhDs unlimited, and that has a payback. When you make a small tweak on billions of dollars, it pays off, but the ability for a smaller company to be able to do that rigorous execution and optimization, it just wasn’t possible. Even if it was possible, it’s not the right decision because it costs so much. Now we have those capabilities through AI.

Ed Haines

And does that also translate then to if you’re a larger company, you can buy some software that can help you with that, but suddenly you’re a smaller company and maybe the software is a little harder to actually be able to get that kind of outcome from?

Greg Giesecke

The software side has a lot to do with scale, but it mostly has to do with Walmart is a macro general merchandise retail company and there’s tons of software that’s built for what they do. Smaller companies often operate in little niches of the economy that do weird things. And when you operate in a bespoke slice of the economy, you have more of those linchpin concepts that say our business is greenfield across capabilities. We need supply chain across the board, but the way we talk about units of measure or the way we drive bills of material, that’s weird for us. So every business has those linchpins. In a smaller business, they have, I think, an outsized impact. And again, you don’t have nine figures of money to put on a solution behind that. Now we have the ability to solve in an enterprise solution, solutions for these smaller businesses.

Brian Betkowski

You’d mentioned in the past in conversations that we’ve had around focusing on the right things, especially for small companies like, “Hey, if you have super high margins in one product line, let’s focus on getting inventory. And if we have more inventory that we need, that’s okay because I make a lot of money in that product.” Talk to us a little more about how you’re talking about prioritization with clients.

Greg Giesecke

Yeah. So I’d say the prioritization and the optimization side of it are the two words we’re talking about a lot because it’s easy to think that the rule that was put in place last year, the CFO had us in staff and told us this is how we need to operate and we’re running that process. That’s what a lot of organizations do. They have kind of watershed moments, they have a big impact, and then they execute a plan. But with the level of volatility we’re seeing, you’re running optimized at this point and now you’ve got totally different factors. So maybe cost has gone way up and your margin is a lot tighter. There are a lot of scenarios that play out. One of the biggest things we see is that simple sourcing decisions, you buy this product from Indonesia, it’s the best quality and the cheapest item. Then tariffs went nuts.

All of a sudden, this isn’t a swing of 5% or 10% in a commodity; this is a 40% move. So all of a sudden, a much more expensive option is the cheapest option because that moved. And those changes don’t happen once and then stay for 18 months. They could be changing every month, every quarter.

Ed Haines

They could be changing while the container’s on its way.

Greg Giesecke

Yeah.

Ed Haines

Already bought the product, right? Yeah.

Brian Betkowski

So what about in businesses where… So if someone’s out there hearing you say, okay, let’s up the frequency of making these decisions, but their lead time, their general lead time in their supply chain is very long, let’s call it six months or more, how do they balance what you’re saying with the realities of their world?

Greg Giesecke

Yeah, there’s two things to go into that. One, we are still in the real world with natural constraints. We can’t make a change today and have it show up tomorrow, but the more of an exposure we have to those lead times, that’s where the majority of the risk comes in. So in the supply chain space, we talk all the time about it’s really a study of risk. Back in the 80s, we were talking about putting it together and having connectedness and efficiency. Now it’s really, those are table stakes, understanding end-to-end information flows, table stakes, and it’s being able to identify where’s it most important for you to drive that optimization function and answer that. And lead time’s a good one where everybody thinks about, I got to know what my customer wants, and that demand planning function is top of mind for a lot of leaders.

But we’ve been recently working with a handful of businesses where if I had a dollar to spend on getting your demand plan more clear and being able to accurately guess what your customer needs or forecasting the lead time, that latter is actually where more of the exposure is right now. It’s volatile, but it’s also a lot of times predictable. We work with a client who has a lot of exposure to kind of a weather related events. So when there’s a rainy season, your lead time’s a month or two longer. I don’t need to account for that when it’s not, but I’ve got to have the ability to identify those trends, understand what product comes from where, and then be able to see just like we do with customer demand, you sell more turkeys in November than you do in February. During some times of the year, your lead time is predictably longer.

So our ability to go pretty far up the maturity curve for some smaller businesses, like you mentioned, Ed, to really say, how do we double down our investment in that? And we could have done this five, 10 years ago, but it would’ve cost a whole lot more and volatility wasn’t quite as high. So the cost is now down and the benefit is now up. So we’re seeing both sides of the business case really expand for us.

Brian Betkowski

So when you say forecast lead time, if someone’s out there listening to this going like, “What are you talking about? I know the lead times, my vendor’s telling me the lead times.” What do you mean by that?

Greg Giesecke

Yeah. So one of the most common misconceptions we see is that what your vendors tell you is what you’re experiencing. And this gets to a lot of this concept of before I get ready for anything around AI optimization, I’ve really got to get my data in order. And that’s what we see a lot is do we really understand when you identified a need, probably when you placed a purchase order, and then what most companies have 10 to 20 dates in between there that sometimes mean different things, and then when did it actually show up? But that ability to measure that lead time is frankly just never what you think it is. And something that happens in the supply chain space, I think of it as a study of risk, but a lot of practitioners have their supply chain function not as a bunch of mathematicians, it’s a bunch of execution people.

So it’s very focused tacticians who escalate and thinking of your lead time as, “Well, that was an outlier. I had to go figure out that shipment and why it wasn’t here. It got hung up in the port.” That’ll never happen again is essentially the assumption you’re saying, but in reality, it happens consistently, a statistical amount we can track, and then we can know if we want to cover for those anomalies, here’s what that looks like. So again, that’s kind of the optimization.

Ed Haines

So in a way, what you’re saying is where maybe the human was playing a role before, typically in the calculation element, that starts to shift because we have tools like AI and other software, but then actually the human element actually becomes the management of that supply chain, the escalation of that supply chain, that’s actually where the value comes from. That’s really interesting, right?

Greg Giesecke

I mean, large businesses that we work with have billions of dollars supply chains that operate on a solution, but really on a spreadsheet because the spreadsheet is where a human can apply all the institutional knowledge they have. I know it’s not really in the data, but here’s what we need to do.

Ed Haines

I download it.

Greg Giesecke

The tool doesn’t do exactly what I need and it’s too much of a hassle to get it sorted out to do what I need. So I’m just going to do it basically on an industrialized napkin. And you do that math manually and it becomes an incredibly labor-intensive thing. And that’s what the job becomes.

Ed Haines

So when we look at these, say for smaller companies, instead of running a spreadsheet, you’re running maybe an AI application that you built from your own requirements and it’s like spreadsheet plus as opposed to software minus in a sense. And so when you see people doing that, how are they using that? How are they changing the parameters and changing that software? What sort of things are they able to do with that flexibility?

Greg Giesecke

Yeah. So again, it kind of gets to the 80/20 rule where for most of your business, it does need to be direct and clear and deterministic and controlled. And the ability to seamlessly blend just straightforward math that says, “Here’s how we operate on a straightforward basis with no exceptions.” That’s the majority of the skews or items that run through a warehouse, but all the problems come from those 20% outliers. So what we do is sit down with the planners on an extremely fast, iterative basis and say, “What is that problem? That problem isn’t item A that does something weird. It’s actually a rule and let’s identify it and see what it applies to.” And that process of iteration, just like we think about agile software development, that process of rapid agile, tell me what’s weird about your business and then begin to build the data, catalog the rules.

We’re getting to creating the stuff that’s needed for the automation process that can streamline a lot of that. And then they’re able to say, “All right, vendors, our lead time’s gone up from 120 to 125 days. What happens? Let’s manage your partners rather than just thinking about get the data, get in the spreadsheet, clean it up.” And I think our ability to work with them and balance that industrialized, here’s what it needs to do and rapidly build new capabilities and be dynamic is kind of the magic.

Brian Betkowski

So imagine we have a client or a listener that’s, let’s call it just to make the math easy, $100 million distribution manufacturing company, something in that space. And they’re thinking to themselves, all right, supply chain, make my team more efficient, but my team’s like four people and I’m trying to do the business case. I’m like, I can’t even imagine that to do it with less than these four people, but I imagine I could do it with three. So my business case is one FTE in the supply chain group. And I think the answer is no, there’s another way to look at it. And then I know you guys, I’d love to hear you talk about that a little more because of the strategy finance bend on this. Yeah.

Greg Giesecke

Yeah. I mean, supply chain is an execution of a process and it does require some process engineering and let’s make it a more efficient process, but that is at least second or third to the performance of the function. So those four people, our goal is almost never to do that with less. We’ve got some large scale clients that have hundreds of buyers and the benefit of going from 130 buyers to 130 FTEs still pales in comparison to the operational benefits. And to your point, there’s kind of two sides of this. Companies generally have some blend of this, but it’s either you’ve got revenue sitting on your front door, you’re not letting it into your building because you don’t have the product, you don’t have the availability. Businesses on this side, if most of those are high margin businesses that feel the pain on any product that’s waiting that increases the risk of a customer going elsewhere, that’s the money.

That’s where the value case really comes from. And the other side is how do we be more efficient? So a lot of the clients that we work with have extremely strong relationships with their customers, really tight commitments, and they buy that, that’s in their bones. And because of that, they’ve kind of thrown money at the problem of never let their customer down. So inventory continues to grow. SKU count continues to grow. Anybody can do what they need to service the customer, and that’s the opposite of the optimization function. So those two things, turning inventory into cash, when interest rates are a couple of percent, it’s not that compelling of a business case, but we’ve seen most CFOs who haven’t cared about cheap money in the past really start to have that conversation in the past couple of years. And I think the key is to have this good news story of not only is the challenge more prevalent, but the solution is more available, especially as we start to think further down market.

Brian Betkowski

So I’m just going to make you do some mental math here. We’ll do it on a hundred million dollar company to make the math hopefully easier. But to put that into reality, a hundred million dollar company who might be able to free up, maybe if they could, free up one FTE of a supply chain person and saves, I don’t know, loaded, let’s just say, make the math easy, $100,000 to the bottom line. Give that example of what that could mean inventory reduction or what that could mean in lost sales to just the generic company.

Greg Giesecke

Yeah. So lost sales is by far the biggest one, and there’s a couple of metrics to think about. One is how in stock are you? How many empty shelves do you have? How much product is not there that orders are waiting on? And what generally happens is it’s your most important product. It’s your fast movers that you run out of. It’s the volatile items. So even if you’re out of stock of 5% of your items, shelves are empty, you could have 10, 20% of your demand, $20 million worth of orders sitting there and think of it as rotting, and that does not age well. And maybe your customers are okay with that backlog, but there is a huge amount of risk to that. So if we’re able to impact a couple of points on that service level where product is in stock, your fill rate sees an outsized benefit to that.

So in a company that has 20, 30, 40% margins, the value of creating $20 million worth of backlog, making a, let’s say 50% improvement to that at 50% margins, you’re down to millions of dollars versus one, two, three FTEs. And the other challenge is we see adding an FTE probably made sense, right? Most of these leaders though, I think we need more people in the supply chain function. It just never happens. It does not get prioritized. When you add that headcount into your budget, it’s not one year, it’s forever. You never really go backwards. You’re thinking about at least 10 years. So managing that long-term loaded cost versus the capabilities. So everything we’re looking at right now is taking those four people who probably know exactly how your business runs. They don’t need to be supply chain optimization experts. That’s what the automation does for you.

So enabling them with tools of really advanced capabilities, we’re creating could be creation of $5 million worth of earnings. That’s not just revenue that we’ll figure out what that is. These margin businesses get significant dollars on the bottom line, and that’s the kind of cost benefit that we need to go through is realizing the value is significantly going up and the capabilities are there. What we see all the time though is, yeah, but can I really do it? There’s so much of, is it really going to materialize? So yeah, we could have bought some software, but gosh, everybody at the club says they’ve failed at those implementations too. And that’s the other side of starting with your data, starting with your business, and then how do we get to parity? Here’s what you do today performance-wise. Let me prove to you absolute that our solution does at least that well.

Then we have a scalable platform we build on from there. That’s really our concept that we’re working from is let me prove to you that we can drive the value before we ever make any significant change. And again, that’s something that the rapid development of these solutions enables us.

Brian Betkowski

Yeah. I think we’ve also seen it’s this horrible spiral, especially in smaller mid-sized companies, excuse me, where data’s a little messy, then maybe you do something outside the system in a spreadsheet, which then gets data a little more out of sync and it’s just this horrible spiral. And so the feeling of a supply chain person is I’m always behind. How could I ever catch up? And some of the math you’re talking about is scary and is overwhelming, and so how can I ever get a chance to catch up? I think that’s what we see in a lot of small and mid-size companies, right?

Greg Giesecke

And I think one of the biggest challenges we see in that environment is the trust between the supply chain organization and the broader company. So once you move onto that spreadsheet and you say, “Trust me, it’s in here somewhere. I’ve got this in this world.” A, anytime I need information, I have to call you or email you. So you spend

Ed Haines

All

Greg Giesecke

Your time unwinding that spreadsheet, and B, I don’t trust the data. So squeaky wheel says, “We’re out of this product. Customer ordered something, it didn’t happen. CEO’s going to hear about it.” That happens one out of every hundred orders. And when you have the data to be able to communicate to the sales team, “Here’s what’s happening, here’s what you need to go through,” that proactivity, it takes a pretty big move to get out of that spiral. So being able to talk to a sales team about here’s our in-stock percentage, here’s where the risks are, and here’s what we need to be able to work together on, that takes a lot of data and a lot of proactivity with them that your teams just can’t get out of. So in addition to the spiral that took you down, once we can get to that parity and start to build on it, you start to get the flywheel that goes in the right direction too, where sales cares, they believe their supply chain team, and they can trust that, oh, that product that we launched, it’s probably going to be a better situation than it was last year, but that’s a significant change to break that trust across the organization.

Brian Betkowski

You’re painting kind of a maturity model.

Greg Giesecke

Yep.

Brian Betkowski

Talk to us a little more about as people move up that maturity model and they get outside of the supply chain data world, you talk about sales, there’s a lot of things that they can do to integrate with sales better, other processes they can put in place. Some of them are just meetings, but they’re meetings for a purpose. Talk about some of those as you move up the maturity curve.

Greg Giesecke

Yeah. So think about the history of supply chain. It really wasn’t a standalone function in the 80s. It was like the 90s was a big maturity of this thing that was there. It’s not buyers or admins that warehouse people that drive this through. It’s a unique function. And the reason it wasn’t thought about as a unique function is where we’ve come full circle where it’s really a pretty core nucleus of the business. So integrated business planning or sales and operations planning is one of those things that was wherever you think you’re at in the maturity curve, you want to be taking two big steps forward. So that integrated function where sales talks to operations, the chain of information is connected between those two, that’s really where a lot of this unlocks. I wonder if we should raise or lower our prices. Supply chain is the interconnective tissue on that.

How are we doing on this product? How should we expand? Where should we move into next? A lot of that de-risking and that data comes from the supply chain function. So as the chain name alludes, if that is all broken, a lot of stuff within the business just doesn’t hang together. So we see you start again, supply chain’s a chain, you generally feel you address problems on the left side of that and then they’re felt further downstream. But as that hardens and you can trust it, that’s when we start to see pricing and product management and more complex things happening on marketing strategies. There’s a lot of stuff that’s available to you that just doesn’t exist. We have a lot of vendors who right now are placing orders for what they need in the month of October. How much are they going to order from November?

No idea. Could be zero, could be four or five months of supply, and their vendors have no concept of that. But being able to give that longer term view, you’re a better partner externally, you’re working better internally. Again, I don’t mean to say it’s the solution to everything, but it does become really a chain to a lot of issues you can see across the business.

Ed Haines

Excellent.

Brian Betkowski

Yeah. As always, I learned a lot. Yeah. So what are the hot topics that other clients are talking about right now as far as what’s going on in the market? I mean, we know the things we see on the news. And generally volatility, but what are some other specifics that are keeping people up?

Greg Giesecke

Yeah, so it kind of gets down to how do I de-risk my business from whatever’s coming up next? How can I save some money? And then some businesses, this is one of those you either feel it or you don’t, and great for you if you don’t, but do you acutely feel supply chain issues right now? And most of the businesses that we talk to get too far down the issue curve where it does become the most important problem to the CEO of the business that we have a backlog of three, four months of supply. Our inventory has consistently increased over the past nine months. And I think one of the issues we see is that ability to proactively address a lot of those points. And how do I not get into that position? And over the next two years, we will have times of a lot of volatility and times that feel like they’re fairly stable.

And I think the important thing to think about is when it is really hard, we can address those points through partnership with you, managed service, let’s lock arms, let’s address those when they’re really hard. But also when your business is feeling a time of kind of stability, let’s jump in together and address those issues too. So that’s a lot of what we’re hearing is kind of how do I either put out on biggest fire or how do I get ahead of some of it? And I think in both scenarios we can help with that.

Brian Betkowski

So how long, it depends, which is the right consulting answer, but just give listeners an idea. Small, medium sized company, and we’re not talking about Walmart supply chain here. I’m talking about small or medium size company to get your arms around the data situation and get to parity, get a process to parity, what are we talking?

Greg Giesecke

Yeah. Orders of magnitude, we were talking a year. I’d say a few years ago, we were looking at these problems and saying, “Okay, let’s begin a big technology journey.” Vendors can tell you however long they think it’s going to be, but you know it’s going to be around a year to get your house in order, go through the process, get back to stable. Now, rather than talking about I guarantee it’s going to be a year or 12 months, we can literally address some of these issues in a month. And that’s this concept of get to parity and then solve a problem. And one of the biggest things that people talk about is the sheer magnitude of the capabilities that AI is giving to us. And it’s crazy. The magnitude is enormous, but the real power that we’re feeling is this iterative approach. It enables that iteration.

Ed Haines

So what would the first step in that be exactly? When you say get to parity, I mean, break that down just a touch more. What would the first step be?

Greg Giesecke

Yes, to Brian’s point, it depends, but it is oftentimes the first step for most businesses is understanding that data foundation. So most of the clients we work with have recently gone through some level of an ERP transformation or getting their kind of data house in order. I think that’s probably because if we didn’t do that, there’s no chance that we can start to feel this issue. Our biggest problem is we don’t even know what’s going on. So that’s usually the first step is some level of financial backbone, a data structure that makes sense for it. But it’s by no means 100% accurate. And that becomes our first step is to really come in, get to know your business. And then again, we call it a linchpin. So I can come in and get to know a company and think about all the capabilities and most of them are really similar to the last client’s capabilities.

But the key is there’s three, four, five things that are true, maybe only for that business. So you sell shoes through a retail environment, you sell home goods to interior designers, or you sell food. A lot of the capabilities are the same, but the ones that really matter are totally different. And that’s where I think the kind of traditional strategy led management consulting mindset that we come in with, with having done this for 20 years in the supply chain planning space, that lets us quickly identify what matters for you. Then we can build that bespoke capability. So out of the box, a software product could meet 80% of your capabilities, but if we don’t figure out that 20%, none of it really matters. And odds are your whole business is operating on a spreadsheet because those linchpins are pulled out. They don’t make sense and hang it all together.

Brian Betkowski

This is the SaaS dilemma, which is that SaaS made total sense and you had to just deal with those problems prior to the AI world because it wasn’t practical to build your own solutions here. And so you got 80% of it with the SaaS solution. You either customize or you got by or you did it in a spreadsheet for the other 20%. And now I think that’s what everyone’s questioning, which is why do we have to do that anymore? Can we just get the solution that I need? And that’s what we’re talking about.

Ed Haines

Or even what we’ve seen in other cases, being able to build out that first proof of concept, if you like, actually doesn’t need to stay around and stick around either. That can then become the requirements for a larger piece of software. I mean, really we’re talking about less the technology and actually getting the outcome and being able to play around and get an idea of the outcome and then be able to scale in other ways if you need to or stick around with the spreadsheet plus.

Greg Giesecke

Yeah. And a lot of times, especially in the supply chain space, we hear leaders say, don’t customize. We want it to be out of the box. We want everything to be standard. And that’s true for almost everything. But the key is that this product operates on a weekly cycle. This SaaS product doesn’t do exactly what you need. And the ability to balance that, these need to be standard, do what best practices, issue a PO, communicate to your vendors, manage lead time this way, that plus, and you’re unique. So there’s these two statements that live right next to each other that say, you need to operate like every business does because we’ve solved this problem and you’re a unicorn that has a unique problem. And both of those can be true.

Brian Betkowski

It’s just so hard. I’ve seen it firsthand in our own business, but I’ve definitely seen it where you feel like some of those uniquenesses are what make your company special or why your customers love you or whatever that is. And it’s hard to convince yourself otherwise in a lot of cases.

Greg Giesecke

Right. And that’s the key to identify what you need to not give up on and then let’s get to standard and be able to enable both.

Brian Betkowski

Yeah. What else?

Ed Haines

Yeah.

Brian Betkowski

Anything else on your mind?

Greg Giesecke

No, this was great. I do think this kind of concept of the problem’s bigger, but so is the solution. We’ve been talking about everybody’s got their kind of whatever the story was that’s happened over the past six or seven years in your business. And it can feel like a negative doom and gloom statement when we think about it, but there is kind of light around this other corner that says at the same time we’re seeing way more volatility. We’re also introducing the capability to deal with that volatility. So it is kind of a good-news story.

Ed Haines

And as much as you might be missing out on revenue, your competitor could be actually adding more revenue because they are getting it right. So wherever there’s disruption, there’s also opportunity.

Greg Giesecke

And the concept of how long does it take? I don’t know exactly how long it is for your business, but it’s fast. And not only is it fast for you, but it’s fast for your competitors. It’s fast for this other thing that you don’t even know you’re competing against yet. So knowing how fast the market’s moving plus the situation that we’re in, it does feel like kind of the time is now. So we’re having a lot of, feels like fairly urgent conversations to get moving.

Brian Betkowski

Well, this is good. Well, everyone appreciates the work you’re putting into it and I know our clients do, and I enjoyed having you on.